Airline Abuse and the Somewhat Frequent Flyer

Usually at some point during almost every flight, someone comes on the PA system and says something to the effect, “We know you have a lot of options when it comes to flying and we thank you for choosing us.” It’s a nice sentiment, it certainly reveals the truth of modern air travel and acknowledges the fact that some of us don’t just book the lowest fare ticket, we stay loyal to one or two airlines. I’m convinced of the advantages of airline loyalty, although I realize not everyone agrees, but what I don’t understand is why airlines don’t really care.

That’s not quite fair, airlines do care about some of their loyal customers, the uber elite. Most airlines employ a multi-tier system of loyalty, with the lowest being regular but not super frequent fliers and the top being constant, always on the go road warriors. It is this second class of the top elite fliers that airlines really care about.

The top frequent flyers spend a stunning amount of money and the airlines of course know this. I completely understand why airlines bend over backwards to keep their top customers happy, it just makes sense. But there’s a huge number of us who don’t fall into either the lowest or top categories, but who I selfishly think are important as well.

I have Gold status with US Airways, the threshold for which is 50,000 air miles a year. I fly much more every year, but not solely on US Airways due to lack of availability. You’d think though that they’d care at least a smidgen about my business. I realize I’m not booking hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of travel every year, but my business can’t be completely without merit, can it? Over the years we frequent fliers have seen a slow degradation in available perks. The most important to me now are: upgrades on domestic flights, extra mileage accrual and access to Alliance partner lounges during international travel. It’s not much, but it’s something and combined these factors help add a tiny extra bit of decorum and comfort to an otherwise miserable flying experience.

I got ticked off the other day because I had received one of those domestic upgrades, albeit on a short, one-hour flight, but it made be really happy. I knew I’d have some room to relax and perhaps sleep on the early morning flight. I was happy until I got to the airport and found out they decided to revoke that upgrade and refused to tell me why. Furthermore, the exit row seat I had originally booked had been given away, so I was left with my choice of middle row seats. I was furious.

I wasn’t angry for just losing the upgrade, it’s an hour flight and I’ve survived much worse. It was the fact no one had bothered to me about it and no one seemed all that interested in the fact I’d been royally screwed. There’s no problem emailing me when I do get an upgrade, but when it comes to revoking it the same courtesy vanishes.

This made me start thinking about other sectors of the hospitality industry and I realized that no one else treats their guests or passengers as badly as the airlines. Hotels bend over backwards to make everyone’s travel experiences as pleasant as possible and if you have status with them, you truly feel like you’re king (or queen) for a day. I can’t imagine a hotel ever pulling a stunt like US Airways did with me, it’s just not how they operate. Once a space is given it would take something extraordinary to revoke it, especially from someone whose elite status is basically a sign saying, “I’m loyal to you, please don’t punch me in the face.”

US Airways isn’t alone in treating their passengers, especially the mediocre elites, badly. Everyone does it. Everyone wants their elite fliers to feel like they’re important, but when push comes to shove it’s only the smallest minority of frequent fliers that truly capture the airline’s interest.

This won’t change, it’s too ingrained in the airline’s DNA, but it’s a shame. It’s a shame that I will probably never feel like a welcome guest on any flight I take, but rather just another body to process through the flying cattle car.

What do you think? Are airlines ignoring an important part of their base or am I overreacting?

Subscribe and get my free ebook!

Subscribe to the Adlabyrinthempire newsletter and get a free copy of my new book, "My Favorite 50 Trip Photos."

By: Mike

Matt has a true passion for travel. As someone who has a bad case of the travel bug, Matt travels the world in order to share tips on where to go, what to see and how to experience the best the world has to offer. Also follow Matt on , and

6 Responses

  1. Kelly @LifeOptimist

    No Matt, I don’t think you’re over-reacting. I’m really surprised (maybe I shouldn’t be?) that you had an upgrade taken away. They should have offered to compensate you on a return or future flight.
    Did you the head office? Maybe let them know you have a blog where *a whole bunch* of people are now informed of their business practices.

    Reply
    • Mike

      No, I haven’t really reached out. The incident just made me start thinking more than anything out. US Air was singled out because it’s who I fly, but I doubt their behavior is unique. It’s unfortunately the nature of the US commercial airline industry. I’ve been loyal to US Air for a while now and overall it’s been great. Just disappointed more than anything else.

      Reply
  2. autisticglobetrotting

    I know how you feel1
    We are premier executives on United and travel with two special needs kids so we qualify for United’s Economy Plus.Last month we had an unpleasant incident when even though I had the tickets booked months in advance and watched over our seats like a hawk we were put in the back of the plane near a lavatory(which made my autistic&alfactory sensitive son sick).Bottom line even if you play by THEIR rules they WILL drop the ball on you once in a while.

    Reply
  3. Jen Pollack Bianco

    I don’t think major US carriers care about their most loyal customers either. I’m a long time 1K/million mile flyer on United and I had a lawsuit worthy incident with a gate agent at O’Hare during the summer. I have spent hours dealing with the customer service person (who doesn’t have a phone number that I can call her). In fact, I only got her to return a call once because I left a message that “if my call is not returned by 5pm tomorrow, I will be ing feminist attorney Gloria Allred.” The lack of care and redress on their part is insulting. The incident was so horrifying I know what I should do is sue them, but I don’t have the time, funds, or energy to pursue a harassment case. Nor do I even have a phone number where I the customer service agent who is supposedly handling my case. They just don’t care.

    Reply
  4. Savvy Triper

    That’s ridiculous. You’re dead on about how they should have – at a bare minimum – ed you to explain the situation (and apologize!)

    As far as I’m concerned, when you have a boarding pass in your hand, they need to offer you denied boarding compensation if they are going to take you down a cabin, or off the flight entirely.

    The LEAST they could have done was to restore your exit row seat.

    I do hate US Airways, but sadly I think almost every other airline would have behaved the same way.

    Reply
    • Mike

      I wasn’t happy, obviously, and I did pursue it with customer service after I got home honestly expecting SOMETHING, miles or a free meal voucher – anything. Instead I got a canned apology email and that’s it. I’m a very loyal customer and that’s the treatment they extend? Sigh, but you’re right they’re all the same.

      Reply

Leave a Comment